Hey Heather Ausmus - We may be running into a bug, but it's not clear at this point exactly why you would be seeing this kind of behavior.
I've created a new support case in your secret group so that our support team can help take a deeper look into this. The investigation will take place in Discussion counts in CMR incorrect after 7.0.2 Upgrade
Once we have an understanding of the cause we can post back here in case anyone else in the community runs into the same issue.
Just to close this here, I realized that some content was removed from the community and it actually threw off the community manager reports, so no bug - I'm just a big 'ol dufus.