7 Replies Latest reply on Jan 25, 2018 12:48 AM by sandra.e.marini

    Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?

    awatson2

      Hello,

       

      I'm researching the experience of switching from widgets to tiles in our Cloud instance and am slightly confused by the multiple documents I'm finding comparing the two.

       

      I'm trying to summarize which overview widgets do not have a tile counterpart at this time. For instance, is there an events  view or calendar widget? Text widget?

       

      I'd like to note any widgets we wouldn't be able to recreate in tiles if we were switch out our overview pages from widgets to tiles in the next two months.


      Anyone care to share their experiences? The tiles they are waiting on? Things to consider now when making the switch? Or, even where the latest info might be?

       

      What are the pros and cons for the switch from widgets to tiles? I understand tiles make a mobile experience possible but there are limitations with design. I would like to better understand the ins and outs of this.

       

      Thanks in advance.

        • Re: Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?
          umillm6

          Hi, Angela. We have been working to move our community, Neo, away from widgets since 2015. The Widget and Tile Comparison Grid for Cloud (2016.3) is a great resource. I actually took the information there and made it into a spreadsheet with two tabs (Tiles Only and a Tile and Widget Comparison chart) to help our community move from widgets to tiles (see attached*). We also created a toolkit to help people "convert" their Overview pages into Activity + Pages. The response to adopting Tiles and Activity + Pages in our community has varied, but people prefer Tiles once they make the switch. We've provided a lot of help documentation and the option for 30-minute #AskNeo one-on-one sessions to help people make the change, which has been well received.

           

          These are the main talking points we focus on:

          1. Tiles are accessible and dynamic, so you can access them on any device (widgets are not).

          2. Tiles use content that already exists, so if a Page is deleted, you aren't losing actual content. (We had instances when the Formatted Text Widget was used a lot and someone deleted an Overview page and all of the content within those widgets was lost.)

          3. Jive is not developing new widgets, nor is it focusing on fixing bugs in curent widgets. (We are encouraging our community to focus on the latest and best tech available.)

           

          The tiles we are waiting on include an RSS feed tile. We are also waiting on improvements to some of the existing tiles, like the Super List tile, which should be coming in 2017.1.  Social Edge Consulting has developed some great tiles to help fill some of the gaps, including a Blog tile that we use (and love!).

           

          We have found work arounds for nearly every widget that doesn't have a one-to-one tile match by using the Document Viewer or Super List tiles. Personally, I prefer using tiles over widgets because you are working with already created content and the risk of having to start from scratch is much lower. I also think that the tiles look better and the out-of-the-box features serve our community well.

           

          I hope this helps. Please let me know if you have any other questions.

           

           

           

          *Please note that I changed the Tile Categories names in our community. So the standard "Lists - Custom" is "Lists created by you" in our community. To change these names, go to Admin Console > Add-Ons > Tile Categories.

          7 people found this helpful
            • Re: Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?
              awatson2

              Thank you, Maren. This is fantastic. I appreciate this info very much.

               

              Congratulations on making the transition. It sounds like it's going well.

               

              I noticed one change that will affect my group is the lack of a recent content widget. Looks like folks would need to get that info by clicking on the activity page rather than embedding something on the overview page.

               

              Thanks again, Maren. You saved the day.:)

                • Re: Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?
                  Ted Hopton

                  You're right that there is no way to add the Recent Activity to a full landing page, but there is a way to address this for some groups: encourage them to use the Activity page as the landing page. That forces you to be selective in the content that you present on the landing page, since you only get the skinny right column to place tiles, plus one tile above the activity stream.

                   

                  It's not the solution for every group, but I like the "less is more" concept and I always try to present it as one of the options to consider.

                  2 people found this helpful
                  • Re: Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?
                    umillm6

                    Hi, Angela. You're welcome!

                     

                    The lack of a Recent Content Tile is one of the areas where we've used the Super List Tile as a workaround. If you go to the place's content page, you can use that feed, or customize for the activity you are looking for, and pull that into a Super List Tile. We have also used Ted's recommendation of steering people to the Activity page.

                    1 person found this helpful
                • Re: Pros and Cons of Switching Now from Widget to Tiles?
                  benfowler

                  Hello Angela Watson. I would suggest reading this: Re: Have you transitioned your community to tiles from widgets? Why or why not?

                   

                  We recently transitioned from widgets to tiles and it was a worthwhile experience in a number of ways. See my post in the discussion above.

                  1 person found this helpful